Addition E · The king's second letter · Greek after 8:12 · unit 16
Any city that disobeys will be destroyed by spear and fire.
Rahlfs 8:12p (lettering not yet checked against Rahlfs) · Swete, Esther 8.1a–24a · .txt · .json
πᾶσα δὲ πόλις ἢ χώρα τὸ σύνολον ἥτις κατὰ ταῦτα μὴ ποιήσῃ δόρατι καὶ πυρὶ καταναλωθήσεται μετʼ ὀργῆς· οὐ μόνον ἀνθρώποις ἄβατος, ἀλλὰ καὶ θηρίοις καὶ πετεινοῖς εἰς τὸν ἅπαντα χρόνον ἔχθιστος κατασταθήσεται.
But every city or country whatsoever that does not act according to this shall be consumed with spear and fire in wrath; it shall be made not only impassable to men, but utterly hateful to beasts and birds as well, for all time.draft English
What the rabbinic bench shows
1 verbatim · 1 motif · 3 flagged · 1 candidates examined and rejected.
- Medieval retranslation: the Additions re-entered Hebrew from Latin (Sefer Yosippon, c. 953; ben Makhir), so this is not ancient reception
- Aramaic: carried by a targum; how the targum came by it is open
Verbatim
'תאבד ותדלק באש ובחרב... אף מקניהם וכל בהמתם' renders Addition E's threat of destruction extended to cattle and beasts, not in MT.
Show the witness text (517 words)
Motif — candidate parallels
Unverified at pair level: in a seeded sample of forty motif pairs, 58% failed the study's own test. Read each as a candidate.
The edict closes with a sanction against non-compliant households (hanging over their own doorway); this is the same structural closing-penalty clause as Addition E's spear-and-fire threat against disobedient cities, absent from MT.
Show the witness text (115 words)
Flagged for further study (3)
Heralds proclaim that whoever does not give peace to Mordecai and the Jews will be put to death and his house made a dunghill -- a specific penalty-for-noncompliance clause matching Addition E's threat against any disobedient city.
Show the witness text (289 words)
The heralds' proclaimed sanction (whoever does not greet Mordecai and the Jews shall have his house made a dunghill) shares the specific universal-destruction-for-noncompliance structure with the plus's decree against any disobedient city.
Show the witness text (288 words)
The midrash imports Darius's sanction clause (Ezra 6:11 -- whoever alters the decree, a beam is pulled from his house and he is impaled on it) directly into the Esther narrative as a penalty-for-noncompliance formula -- structurally matching Addition E's closing sanction clause for any city that disobeys, a specific device MT nowhere supplies for either decree.
Show the witness text (474 words)
Hebrew retroversions
Machine-assisted reconstructions of a Hebrew the Greek might render, made under Tov's principles and used only as search queries. They are hypotheses, not evidence.
וכל עיר ומדינה אשר לא תעשה ככל אלה בחרב ובאש תאכל בחמה ולא לבד לאין עבר לאדם כי אם שנואה גם לחיה ולעוף לכל הימים
וכל עיר או ארץ אשר לא תעשה כדבר הזה באש ובחרב תכלה בחרון אף ולא תהיה לבני אדם למדרך כי אם לשקץ גם לחית השדה ולעוף השמים עד עולם