Witness
Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061)
Parallels (35)
'רעש ורעד חזק מאד וקול בהלה... ופחד ורעד' is a matching cluster of terms (tremor, tumult, terror) across the wording of the plus's 'voices and tumult, thunders and earthquake, confusion,' material found nowhere in MT.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
'וירוצו לקולם כל הארץ... ויקומו כל הגוים על גוי קטן' reproduces across two clauses the plus's 'every nation prepared for war... against a righteous nation,' with no MT counterpart.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
'ויצעק אל ה'... ויגדל המעין ויהי לנחל שוטף' matches across two clauses the plus's distinctive 'they cried out to God... a great river, much water,' an image absent from MT.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
'ויזרח השמש ויאר... ויתרומם הגוי הקטן' matches across two clauses the plus's 'the sun rose... the lowly were exalted,' an image absent from MT.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
'ויש אומרים אליהו ז"ל בא וכתבן' supplies a second, non-royal writer of the memorial alongside the king's scribe — the same doubling the plus makes with 'the king wrote... and Mordecai wrote,' a detail MT lacks.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
'העביר שני קלסנטרין ומושיב הברברי הזה' states from the enemies' side the same replacement-appointment of Mordecai to the eunuchs' post that the plus describes; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
Ahasuerus objects that Israel cannot be destroyed because 'אין אנו יכולים שאין אלקיהם עוזבם כל עיקר' — the enemy conceding the plus's claim that none can oppose God when he wills to save Israel; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
The sages' warning that destroying Israel would unmake 'חקות שמים וארץ' grounds God's unopposable dominion in his making heaven and earth, matching the plus; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
Haman carries his idol on his garments so that bowing equals idolatry — the specific reason the witness gives for Mordecai's refusal, matching the plus's claim it was not insolence or pride; not MT material (MT gives no reason).
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
Mordecai is charged with 'לבטל קלבסים של מלך' and answers 'שאני יהודי' and by Benjamin's precedent — the same accusation of personal insolence that the plus's prayer explicitly denies; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
'אם ישתחוה לי נמצא עובד ע"א' is precisely the plus's reasoning that he would not set a man's glory above God's; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
Mordecai says the Shekhinah rests on his shoulders and so he cannot flatter Haman — refusal framed, as in the plus, as a choice between God's glory and a man's; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
'איסגנטריני של הקב"ה אני וכי איסגנטרין משתחוה להדיוט' — God's herald does not bow to a commoner — the same theological ground the plus gives for refusing prostration; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
Mordecai's message to Esther grounds hope specifically in the Exodus redemption ('כששמט נפשות בכוריהן וטבע שונאיהם בים'), matching the plus's appeal not to overlook the portion redeemed out of Egypt; not MT material (this exchange is absent from MT).
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
The nations are called 'נכרים' while Israel is God's 'עם קרובו' whom none may touch — matching the plus's 'you took Israel out of all the nations... for an everlasting inheritance'; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
R. Shimon b. Yohai's answer — the generation was liable to destruction 'מפני שהשתחוו לצלם' — is exactly the plus's confession that they were handed to their enemies because they glorified other gods; not MT material (MT gives no theological cause).
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
At the very point Addition C's prayer stands, Mordecai himself says destruction was decreed 'מיום שכרו לצלמו של נבוכדנאצר' — the same idolatry-as-cause confession, in the same speaker's mouth; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
Haman's indictment targets Jewish worship itself — synagogues, reciting Shema, praying 'מכניע זדים' — matching the plus's enemies who aim to stop the mouths of those who praise God; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
Haman's idol worn on his garments makes homage to him worship of a man — matching the plus's fear that a mortal king be 'marveled at forever' in God's place; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
Esther is fed Jewish food/seeds rather than the king's fare — a specific dietary abstention matching the plus's claim she never honored the king's banquet; MT says nothing of her diet.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
'לא טעמה כלום אלא משלה ולא משלחנו של מלך' closely matches the plus's 'has not eaten at the table... nor honored the king's banquet'; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
'כשם שאבדתי מבית אבא כך אני אובדת ממך' reads her queenship as pure loss, matching the plus's 'no joy from the day of my change until now'; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
R. Levi's parable of the recruit deliberately raised so his execution will be exemplary matches the plus's reflection on those honored too often by their benefactors; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
The angel beats the sleeping king crying 'כפוי טובה כפוי טובה' at the very moment of his insomnia, matching the plus's charge of doing away with gratitude; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
The king's belated regret over Vashti's death and blame on his seven princes matches the plus's counselors whose persuasion made the ruler a partner in innocent blood; MT never states Vashti was killed, so the regret motif is a genuine addition.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
The sages refuse to judge Vashti for fear the king will later regret it and blame them — a specific self-protective calculation by royal counselors matching the plus's advisers who become partners in innocent blood; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
The same passage makes the advisers, not the king, the culprits who are punished for deceiving him — matching the plus's 'deceiving... the sincere good faith of those who hold power'; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
All night the king sees Haman over him with drawn sword, stripping his purple and crown, seeking to kill him — a specific vision matching the plus's charge that Haman sought to deprive the king of power and life; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
Esther's stated reason for haste — Haman's sons are commanders worldwide poised to revolt at his letters — matches the plus's charge that Haman moved to deprive the king of his power and his life; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
The same sentence makes Haman's sons commanders throughout the world poised to seize power at his word, matching the plus's hidden aim of transferring the dominion; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
Michael's defense that Israel is accused not of idolatry or bloodshed but of keeping God's law matches the plus's royal finding that the Jews are no evildoers but govern themselves by the most just laws, sons of the living God; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
Haman and his ten sons are hanged together on one measured fifty-cubit beam, a single combined execution — matching the plus's 'crucified... together with his whole household' more specifically than MT's separated battle-then-hanging sequence in chapter 9.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
'כולהו עשרה בחד זקיפא אזדקיפו' — all ten sons hanged together on a single stake — matches the plus's combined execution of Haman 'together with his whole household' more specifically than MT's separated battle-then-hanging sequence.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
'לעשות כרצון מרדכי והמן... לרומם אחד ולצלוב אחד' names Mordecai and Haman as the two irreconcilable figures resolved only by raising one and hanging the other — the specific identification Addition F makes of the two dragons; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
Haman and Ahasuerus cast lots over whether the people or the silver falls to each, and the Spirit cries 'ועל עמי ידו גורל' — a lot specifically 'for my people,' matching Addition F's two lots, one for God's people; not the same content as MT's pur (which is only about timing).
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
Flagged for further study (32)
Witness dates Mordecai's dream to 'בשנה השנית למלך אחשורוש' (the second year of Ahasuerus), matching the plus's dating of the dream to Artaxerxes' second year — a detail with no MT basis at all (MT has no dream).
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
R. Shimon answers exactly the plus's implicit question — why this one man is singled out as 'a Jewish man' — with his royal descent and lifelong abstention, a specific reason not supplied by MT.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
Esther is made to ask the king to seat a righteous Jew at the gate as earlier kings seated Daniel, and Mordecai is installed there on that basis — a specific origin-story for his court service that MT does not supply.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
'שני תנינים גדולים זה לקראת זה למלחמה' is the specific image of two great dragons advancing to fight, matching the plus precisely; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
'ויצר לגוי הקטן מאד' matches the plus's righteous nation troubled and fearing destruction; an image with no MT counterpart.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
Mordecai overhears the two eunuchs speaking Tarsian (which he understands from the Chamber of Hewn Stone) and learns of their poison plot — a specific mechanism of discovery matching 'overheard their reasonings and searched out their designs'; not MT (MT gives no mechanism).
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
The king removes Bigthan and Teresh and installs Mordecai in their place as court guard — a specific replacement-appointment matching the plus; MT only records that Mordecai's report was written down, not that he was appointed to their post.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
Harbonah charges that Haman 'היה עם בגתן ותרש באותה עצה' and hated Mordecai from the moment he exposed them — the plus's distinctive claim that Haman's enmity toward Mordecai stemmed specifically from the two eunuchs; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
R. Levi's chain of persecutors — Esau, Pharaoh, Haman, Gog, each improving on the last's scheme of total destruction — matches the plus's 'desired to destroy your inheritance from the beginning'; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
At the threshold Esther prays 'אלי אלי למה עזבתני' facing mortal danger with no helper, at the identical narrative beat where the plus has her cry to God alone, having no helper but him; not MT (MT has no such prayer scene).
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
'ותלבש אסתר מלכות... שלבשתה רוח הקדש' makes donning the royal robes a reception of the Holy Spirit at the very point the plus asks for courage; not MT (MT only records the clothing, with no such empowerment).
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
The witness has Esther call the king 'the lion' ('הושיעני מפי אריה'), the same distinctive epithet the plus uses ('before the lion') for Ahasuerus; not MT (MT never calls the king a lion).
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
'במוך היתה משמשת' — Esther used a barrier device to avoid real union with the gentile king — a concrete practice expressing exactly the plus's abhorrence of the bed of the uncircumcised; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
The doomed children's weeping 'נשמעה בכיתן במרום' immediately precedes God tearing up the decree, matching the plus's 'hear the voice of the despairing, and deliver us from the hand of the wicked'; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
The same clothing-with-ruaḥ-ha-qodesh answers the plus's 'becoming radiant, having called upon God'; goes beyond MT's bare notice of her royal apparel.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
The king turns his face away in fury and Esther, lacking strength, collapses — matching the plus's king inflamed with anger and the queen fainting; this whole scene is absent from MT 5:2.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
Angels force the king's face toward her and his eyes are opened so he extends the sceptre — the same divine reversal the plus ascribes to God changing the king's spirit to gentleness; absent from MT.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
One angel 'הגביה את צוארה' while another stretches the sceptre to reach her — both locate the royal contact specifically at her neck, matching the plus's king touching the golden rod to her neck; not MT (MT has only the sceptre extended, no neck).
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
Angels literally hold up the king's face and three angels attend the throne — matching what the plus has Esther say figuratively, 'I saw you, my lord, as an angel of God'; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
'ולא היה כח באסתר ליגע בו' with an angel drawing her hand to the sceptre matches the plus's collapse while she is speaking; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
The parable of the pig fed generously and then slaughtered explicitly explains Haman's promotion as the cause of his fall ('בתחלה גדל ולבסוף ויתלו את המן'), matching the plus's reflection on those honored too generously growing arrogant; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
Haman is unmasked as a village barber of twenty-two years, forced to bathe and barber Mordecai — matching the plus's insistence that the man second to the throne was in truth of low, alien standing; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
'מכאן שהדיוט קופץ בראש' applies specifically to Haman's own unworthy rise to prominence, matching the plus's charge that this outsider was elevated to second in the kingdom.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
At Haman's crown request the king's face changes: 'זהו שראיתי בחלום שהיה מבקש להרגני' — the specific charge that Haman sought the king's own life, matching the plus; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
Haman's request for the crown is read as a direct bid for the kingship itself, matching the plus's charge that he aimed to transfer the dominion; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
'שבר את החותמות וקרע את האגרת והפר עצתו' — physically annulling Haman's sealed letters — matches the very device of Addition E's second letter, 'do not act on the letters sent by Haman'; MT's solution is a second decree, not annulment of the first.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
God's own answer to Haman's calendar-counting — 'תרין יומין דאתון להון שמחה במפלתו של אותו האיש' — explicitly makes the appointed days joy at Haman's own downfall, matching the plus's theological claim that God turned this day from destruction into joy; goes beyond MT's mere fixing of dates.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
'ידע... שנתקיים החלום' — the dream recognized as fulfilled — matches Addition F's 'not one word of it failed to come to pass'; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
'ויקומו כל הגוים על גוי קטן לאבד זכרו מן הארץ' shares the specific phrase 'destroy his name/memory,' matching the plus's 'gathered together to destroy the name of the Jews'; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
The fasting children cry out, are heard, and the decree is torn up — matching the plus's 'my nation is Israel, who cried out to God and were saved'; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
'ויצר לגוי הקטן מאד ויצעק אל ה'... ויתרומם הגוי הקטן' matches the plus's 'my nation is Israel, who cried out to God and were saved'; not MT material.
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.
'אתה הוא גורלן של בני' turns the pur into a lot belonging specifically to God's children as against the nations — Addition F's distinctive two-lots reading; not MT's pur (which is only about timing).
Text not reproduced: licence not stated — research only, never published verbatim. Consult Yalkut Shimoni on Esther (Remez 1046-1061) at the reference above.